| * = Keeper | |||
| ** = Final year of keeper eligibility | |||
| Pick # | Round | Team | Player |
| 1 | 1 | Killer Bees | Mark Teixeira |
| 2 | 1 | Superheroes | Manny Ramirez |
| 3 | 1 | Armadillos | David Wright |
| 4 | 1 | Peanut Gallery | David Ortiz * |
| 5 | 1 | Homer Gomers | Jason Bay |
| 6 | 1 | Jordan Almonds | Miguel Tejada |
| 7 | 1 | Thunder in Paradise | Vlad Guerrero * |
| 8 | 1 | Monkey Butlers | Carl Crawford |
| 9 | 1 | Larson Lugnuts | vernon wells |
| 10 | 1 | Carpet Cleaners | alex rodriguez * |
| 11 | 1 | World Eaters | bobby abreu |
| 12 | 1 | Army of Darkness | albert pujols * |
| 13 | 1 | Cooperstown | Matt Holliday |
| 14 | 1 | Red Menace | Miguel Cabrera * |
| 15 | 1 | Pumbaas | Johan Santana * |
| 16 | 1 | Chompers | Jimmy Rollins |
| 17 | 2 | Chompers | Grady Sizemore * |
| 18 | 2 | Pumbaas | Victor Martinez |
| 19 | 2 | Red Menace | Ichiro Suzuki |
| 20 | 2 | Cooperstown | Derek Jeter * |
| 21 | 2 | Army of Darkness | Aramis Ramirez |
| 22 | 2 | World Eaters | Jose Reyes * |
| 23 | 2 | Carpet Cleaners | Ryan Howard * |
| 24 | 2 | Larson Lugnuts | Alfonso Soriano * |
| 25 | 2 | Monkey Butlers | Paul Konerko * |
| 26 | 2 | Thunder in Paradise | Carlos Zambrano |
| 27 | 2 | Jordan Almonds | Carlos Beltran * |
| 28 | 2 | Homer Gomers | Michael Young |
| 29 | 2 | Peanut Gallery | Carlos Lee * |
| 30 | 2 | Armadillos | Todd Helton |
| 31 | 2 | Superheroes | Adam Dunn |
| 32 | 2 | Killer Bees | Jake Peavy |
| 33 | 3 | Killer Bees | Derrek Lee |
| 34 | 3 | Superheroes | Francisco Rodriguez |
| 35 | 3 | Armadillos | Roy Oswalt |
| 36 | 3 | Peanut Gallery | Gary Sheffield |
| 37 | 3 | Homer Gomers | Brian Roberts |
| 38 | 3 | Jordan Almonds | Roy Halladay ** |
| 39 | 3 | Thunder in Paradise | Daisuke Matsuzaka |
| 40 | 3 | Monkey Butlers | Chase Utley ** |
| 41 | 3 | Larson Lugnuts | Hideki Matsui |
| 42 | 3 | Carpet Cleaners | Carlos Delgado |
| 43 | 3 | World Eaters | Richie Sexson |
| 44 | 3 | Army of Darkness | Johnny Damon * |
| 45 | 3 | Cooperstown | Julio Lugo |
| 46 | 3 | Red Menace | Juan Pierre |
| 47 | 3 | Pumbaas | Rafael Furcal |
| 48 | 3 | Chompers | Magglio Ordonez |
| 49 | 4 | Chompers | Brett Myers |
| 50 | 4 | Pumbaas | Brian Giles |
| 51 | 4 | Red Menace | Kevin Youkilis |
| 52 | 4 | Cooperstown | Joe nathan |
| 53 | 4 | Army of Darkness | Carlos Guillen |
| 54 | 4 | World Eaters | Andruw Jones ** |
| 55 | 4 | Carpet Cleaners | Mike Piazza |
| 56 | 4 | Larson Lugnuts | Jim Thome |
| 57 | 4 | Monkey Butlers | Travis Hafner ** |
| 58 | 4 | Thunder in Paradise | Stephen Drew |
| 59 | 4 | Jordan Almonds | Mark Teahenn |
| 60 | 4 | Homer Gomers | Torii Hunter |
| 61 | 4 | Peanut Gallery | Josh Beckett |
| 62 | 4 | Armadillos | Josh Barfield |
| 63 | 4 | Superheroes | Ben Sheets |
| 64 | 4 | Killer Bees | J.D. Drew |
| 65 | 5 | Killer Bees | Joe Mauer * |
| 66 | 5 | Superheroes | Michael Barrett |
| 67 | 5 | Armadillos | Pat Burrell |
| 68 | 5 | Peanut Gallery | Scott Rolen |
| 69 | 5 | Homer Gomers | Mariano Rivera |
| 70 | 5 | Jordan Almonds | Adam LaRoche |
| 71 | 5 | Thunder in Paradise | Justin Morneau * |
| 72 | 5 | Monkey Butlers | chipper jones |
| 73 | 5 | Larson Lugnuts | lyle overbay |
| 74 | 5 | Carpet Cleaners | chris carpenter ** |
| 75 | 5 | World Eaters | rocco baldelli |
| 76 | 5 | Army of Darkness | John Lackey |
| 77 | 5 | Cooperstown | Aubrey Huff |
| 78 | 5 | Red Menace | Ramon Hernandez |
| 79 | 5 | Pumbaas | Jeff Francoeur |
| 80 | 5 | Chompers | Barry Bonds |
| 81 | 6 | Chompers | Nomar Garciaparra |
| 82 | 6 | Pumbaas | Jeff Kent |
| 83 | 6 | Red Menace | Troy Glaus |
| 84 | 6 | Cooperstown | C.C. Sabathia |
| 85 | 6 | Army of Darkness | Eric Chavez |
| 86 | 6 | World Eaters | Jason Schmidt |
| 87 | 6 | Carpet Cleaners | Ian Kinsler |
| 88 | 6 | Larson Lugnuts | Orlando Cabrera |
| 89 | 6 | Monkey Butlers | Scott Kazmir |
| 90 | 6 | Thunder in Paradise | Ivan Rodriguez |
| 91 | 6 | Jordan Almonds | Chris Duncan |
| 92 | 6 | Homer Gomers | Adrian Beltre |
| 93 | 6 | Peanut Gallery | Edgar Renteria |
| 94 | 6 | Armadillos | Cole Hamels |
| 95 | 6 | Superheroes | Pedro Martinez |
| 96 | 6 | Killer Bees | Lance Berkman * |
| 97 | 7 | Killer Bees | Joe Crede |
| 98 | 7 | Superheroes | Ervin Santana |
| 99 | 7 | Armadillos | Jonathan Papelbon |
| 100 | 7 | Peanut Gallery | Conor Jackson |
| 101 | 7 | Homer Gomers | Ryan Freel |
| 102 | 7 | Jordan Almonds | Nick Swisher * |
| 103 | 7 | Thunder in Paradise | Alex Rios |
| 104 | 7 | Monkey Butlers | Mike Cameron |
| 105 | 7 | Larson Lugnuts | Barry Zito |
| 106 | 7 | Carpet Cleaners | Nick Markakis |
| 107 | 7 | World Eaters | Howie Kendrick |
| 108 | 7 | Army of Darkness | Brandon Philips |
| 109 | 7 | Cooperstown | John Smoltz |
| 110 | 7 | Red Menace | Placido Polanco |
| 111 | 7 | Pumbaas | Carlos Quentin |
| 112 | 7 | Chompers | Tadahito Iguchi |
| 113 | 8 | Chompers | Jorge Posada |
| 114 | 8 | Pumbaas | Curt Schilling |
| 115 | 8 | Red Menace | Dontrelle Willis |
| 116 | 8 | Cooperstown | Coco Crisp |
| 117 | 8 | Army of Darkness | David Delluci |
| 118 | 8 | World Eaters | Garrett Anderson |
| 119 | 8 | Carpet Cleaners | Jhonny Peralta |
| 120 | 8 | Larson Lugnuts | Jose lopez |
| 121 | 8 | Monkey Butlers | Khalil Greene |
| 122 | 8 | Thunder in Paradise | Rickie Weeks |
| 123 | 8 | Jordan Almonds | Jorge Cantu |
| 124 | 8 | Homer Gomers | Kenji Johjima * |
| 125 | 8 | Peanut Gallery | orlando hudson |
| 126 | 8 | Armadillos | Josh Willingham |
| 127 | 8 | Superheroes | Troy Tulowitzki |
| 128 | 8 | Killer Bees | Craig Monroe |
| 129 | 9 | Killer Bees | Bobby Crosby |
| 130 | 9 | Superheroes | Jermaine Dye * |
| 131 | 9 | Armadillos | Chone Figgins |
| 132 | 9 | Peanut Gallery | Matt Cain |
| 133 | 9 | Homer Gomers | Andy Pettitte |
| 134 | 9 | Jordan Almonds | BJ Ryan |
| 135 | 9 | Thunder in Paradise | Alex Gordon |
| 136 | 9 | Monkey Butlers | Eric Byrnes |
| 137 | 9 | Larson Lugnuts | AJ Burnett |
| 138 | 9 | Carpet Cleaners | Rich Harden |
| 139 | 9 | World Eaters | Mike Mussina |
| 140 | 9 | Army of Darkness | Paul Lo Duca |
| 141 | 9 | Cooperstown | Dave Bush |
| 142 | 9 | Red Menace | Austin Kearns |
| 143 | 9 | Pumbaas | Billy Wagner |
| 144 | 9 | Chompers | Edwin Encarnacion |
| 145 | 10 | Chompers | Jeremy Bonderman ** |
| 146 | 10 | Pumbaas | Hank Blalock |
| 147 | 10 | Red Menace | JJ Putz |
| 148 | 10 | Cooperstown | Curtis Granderson |
| 149 | 10 | Army of Darkness | Chris B. Young |
| 150 | 10 | World Eaters | Randy Johnson |
| 151 | 10 | Carpet Cleaners | Corey Patterson |
| 152 | 10 | Larson Lugnuts | Brian McCann * |
| 153 | 10 | Monkey Butlers | Bobby Jenks |
| 154 | 10 | Thunder in Paradise | Frank Thomas |
| 155 | 10 | Jordan Almonds | Josh Johnson |
| 156 | 10 | Homer Gomers | Trevor Hoffman |
| 157 | 10 | Peanut Gallery | Moises Alou |
| 158 | 10 | Armadillos | Johnny Estrada |
| 159 | 10 | Superheroes | Ryan shealy |
| 160 | 10 | Killer Bees | BJ Upton |
| 161 | 11 | Killer Bees | Brad Lidge |
| 162 | 11 | Superheroes | Daniel Cabrera |
| 163 | 11 | Armadillos | Jason Bartlett |
| 164 | 11 | Peanut Gallery | AJ Pierzynski |
| 165 | 11 | Homer Gomers | Dave Roberts |
| 166 | 11 | Jordan Almonds | Chris Capauno |
| 167 | 11 | Thunder in Paradise | Gary Matthews |
| 168 | 11 | Monkey Butlers | Adam Wainright |
| 169 | 11 | Larson Lugnuts | Freddy Garcia |
| 170 | 11 | Carpet Cleaners | Rich Hill |
| 171 | 11 | World Eaters | Jeremy Hermida |
| 172 | 11 | Army of Darkness | Scott Olsen |
| 173 | 11 | Cooperstown | Francisco Cordero |
| 174 | 11 | Red Menace | David DeJesus |
| 175 | 11 | Pumbaas | Mike Jacobs |
| 176 | 11 | Chompers | Chris Ray |
| 177 | 12 | Chompers | Ken Griffey |
| 178 | 12 | Pumbaas | Garrett Atkins ** |
| 179 | 12 | Red Menace | Brandon Webb * |
| 180 | 12 | Cooperstown | Wilson Betemit |
| 181 | 12 | Army of Darkness | Randy Winn |
| 182 | 12 | World Eaters | Bill Hall * |
| 183 | 12 | Carpet Cleaners | Delmon Young * |
| 184 | 12 | Larson Lugnuts | Ryan Zimmerman * |
| 185 | 12 | Monkey Butlers | Jason Varitek |
| 186 | 12 | Thunder in Paradise | Jacque Jones |
| 187 | 12 | Jordan Almonds | Bengie Molina |
| 188 | 12 | Homer Gomers | Justin Verlander * |
| 189 | 12 | Peanut Gallery | Chad Cordero |
| 190 | 12 | Armadillos | Raul Ibanez ** |
| 191 | 12 | Superheroes | Lastings Milledge |
| 192 | 12 | Killer Bees | Kelly Johnson |
| 193 | 13 | Killer Bees | Kevin Millwood |
| 194 | 13 | Superheroes | Aaron Rowand |
| 195 | 13 | Armadillos | David Eckstein ** |
| 196 | 13 | Peanut Gallery | Dan Johnson |
| 197 | 13 | Homer Gomers | Shea Hillenbrand |
| 198 | 13 | Jordan Almonds | Ryan Garko |
| 199 | 13 | Thunder in Paradise | Jason Isringhausen |
| 200 | 13 | Monkey Butlers | Wily Taveras |
| 201 | 13 | Larson Lugnuts | Javier Vazquez |
| 202 | 13 | Carpet Cleaners | Morgan Ensberg |
| 203 | 13 | World Eaters | Scott Podsednik |
| 204 | 13 | Army of Darkness | Casey Kotchman |
| 205 | 13 | Cooperstown | Gerald Laird |
| 206 | 13 | Red Menace | Hanley Ramirez * |
| 207 | 13 | Pumbaas | Anthony Reyes |
| 208 | 13 | Chompers | Marcus Giles |
| 209 | 14 | Chompers | Xavier Nady |
| 210 | 14 | Pumbaas | Mike Lowell |
| 211 | 14 | Red Menace | Chris Burke |
| 212 | 14 | Cooperstown | Derek Lowe |
| 213 | 14 | Army of Darkness | Chris R. Young * |
| 214 | 14 | World Eaters | Takashi Saito |
| 215 | 14 | Carpet Cleaners | Todd Jones |
| 216 | 14 | Larson Lugnuts | Tom Gordon |
| 217 | 14 | Monkey Butlers | Boof Bonser |
| 218 | 14 | Thunder in Paradise | Ray Durham |
| 219 | 14 | Jordan Almonds | Melvin Mora |
| 220 | 14 | Homer Gomers | Akinori Iwamura |
| 221 | 14 | Peanut Gallery | Aaron Hill |
| 222 | 14 | Armadillos | Brandon McCarthy |
| 223 | 14 | Superheroes | Sammy Sosa |
| 224 | 14 | Killer Bees | Chris Iannetta |
| 225 | 15 | Killer Bees | Cameron Maybin |
| 226 | 15 | Superheroes | Ty Wiggington |
| 227 | 15 | Armadillos | Octavio Dotel |
| 228 | 15 | Peanut Gallery | Trot Nixon |
| 229 | 15 | Homer Gomers | Craig Biggio |
| 230 | 15 | Jordan Almonds | Jeff Suppan |
| 231 | 15 | Thunder in Paradise | Kevin Mench |
| 232 | 15 | Monkey Butlers | Jose Contreras |
| 233 | 15 | Larson Lugnuts | Kei Igawa |
| 234 | 15 | Carpet Cleaners | Luke Scott |
| 235 | 15 | World Eaters | Jon Garland |
| 236 | 15 | Army of Darkness | Jason Kendall |
| 237 | 15 | Cooperstown | Kevin Kouzmanoff |
| 238 | 15 | Red Menace | Ian Snell |
| 239 | 15 | Pumbaas | Milton Bradley |
| 240 | 15 | Chompers | Josh Bard |
| 241 | 16 | Chompers | Nick Johnson |
| 242 | 16 | Pumbaas | Jason Giambi ** |
| 243 | 16 | Red Menace | John Patterson |
| 244 | 16 | Cooperstown | Cliff Lee |
| 245 | 16 | Army of Darkness | Chien Ming Wang |
| 246 | 16 | World Eaters | Carl Pavano |
| 247 | 16 | Carpet Cleaners | Tom Glavine |
| 248 | 16 | Larson Lugnuts | Dustin Pedroia |
| 249 | 16 | Monkey Butlers | Pedro Feliz |
| 250 | 16 | Thunder in Paradise | Greg Maddux |
| 251 | 16 | Jordan Almonds | Ryan Braun |
| 252 | 16 | Homer Gomers | Brad Penny * |
| 253 | 16 | Peanut Gallery | Dan Haren ** |
| 254 | 16 | Armadillos | Brandon Inge |
| 255 | 16 | Superheroes | Joe Blanton |
| 256 | 16 | Killer Bees | Nate Robertson |
| 257 | 17 | Killer Bees | Francisco Liriano |
| 258 | 17 | Superheroes | Bronson Arroyo * |
| 259 | 17 | Armadillos | Jose Guillen |
| 260 | 17 | Peanut Gallery | Corey Koskie |
| 261 | 17 | Homer Gomers | Vicente Padilla |
| 262 | 17 | Jordan Almonds | Jonny Gomes |
| 263 | 17 | Thunder in Paradise | Nick Punto |
| 264 | 17 | Monkey Butlers | Shane Victorino |
| 265 | 17 | Larson Lugnuts | Emil Brown |
| 266 | 17 | Carpet Cleaners | Wily Mo Pena |
| 267 | 17 | World Eaters | Mark Prior |
| 268 | 17 | Army of Darkness | Huston Street ** |
| 269 | 17 | Cooperstown | Freddy Sanchez * |
| 270 | 17 | Red Menace | J.J. Hardy |
| 271 | 17 | Pumbaas | Dan Uggla * |
| 272 | 17 | Chompers | Tim Hudson |
| 273 | 18 | Chompers | Brad Hawpe * |
| 274 | 18 | Pumbaas | James Shields |
| 275 | 18 | Red Menace | Dioner Navarro |
| 276 | 18 | Cooperstown | Adrian Gonzalez * |
| 277 | 18 | Army of Darkness | Luis Gonzalez |
| 278 | 18 | World Eaters | Chris Duffy |
| 279 | 18 | Carpet Cleaners | Johnathan broxton |
| 280 | 18 | Larson Lugnuts | Casey Blake |
| 281 | 18 | Monkey Butlers | Nook Logan |
| 282 | 18 | Thunder in Paradise | Sean Casey |
| 283 | 18 | Jordan Almonds | Hunter Pence |
| 284 | 18 | Homer Gomers | Kenny Lofton |
| 285 | 18 | Peanut Gallery | Jake Westbrook |
| 286 | 18 | Armadillos | Erik Bedard * |
| 287 | 18 | Superheroes | Chad Tracy ** |
| 288 | 18 | Killer Bees | Termel Sledge |
| 289 | 19 | Killer Bees | Felix Hernandez * |
| 290 | 19 | Superheroes | Robinson Cano ** |
| 291 | 19 | Armadillos | Corey Hart |
| 292 | 19 | Peanut Gallery | Scott Linebrink |
| 293 | 19 | Homer Gomers | Prince Fielder ** |
| 294 | 19 | Jordan Almonds | Felipe Lopez ** |
| 295 | 19 | Thunder in Paradise | Joel Zumaya * |
| 296 | 19 | Monkey Butlers | Anibal Sanchez * |
| 297 | 19 | Larson Lugnuts | Jered Weaver * |
| 298 | 19 | Carpet Cleaners | jason Kubel |
| 299 | 19 | World Eaters | David Ross * |
| 300 | 19 | Army of Darkness | Rich Aurilia |
| 301 | 19 | Cooperstown | Russell Martin * |
| 302 | 19 | Red Menace | Michael Cuddyer * |
| 303 | 19 | Pumbaas | Jack Wilson |
| 304 | 19 | Chompers | Aaron Harang * |