| * = Keeper | ||||
| ** = Final year of keeper eligibility | ||||
| Pick | Round | Team / Player | ||
| 1 | 1 | Army of Darkness Pujols ** | ||
| 2 | 1 | City Superheroes Chase Utley | ||
| 3 | 1 | Cooperstown Matt Holliday * | ||
| 4 | 1 | Lugnuts Jimmy Rollins | ||
| 5 | 1 | Jordan Almonds Prince Fielder | ||
| 6 |
1 |
Armadillos David Wright * | ||
| 7 | 1 | Thunder Vlad Guerrero ** | ||
| 8 | 1 | Red Menace Miguel Cabrera ** | ||
| 9 | 1 | Gomers Derek Jeter | ||
| 10 | 1 | Pumbaas Johan Santana ** | ||
| 11 | 1 | World Eaters Carl Crawford | ||
| 12 | 1 | Chompers A-Rod ** | ||
| 13 | 1 | Gluteus Maximus Teixeira * | ||
| 14 | 1 | Carpet Cleaners Travis Hafner | ||
| 15 | 1 | Peanut Gallery David Ortiz ** | ||
| 16 | 1 | Monkey Butlers Alfonso Soriano | ||
| 17 | 2 | Monkey Butlers Robinson Cano | ||
| 18 | 2 | Peanut Gallery Carlos Lee ** | ||
| 19 | 2 | Carpet Cleaners Ryan Howard ** | ||
| 20 | 2 | Gluteus Maximus Jake Peavy * | ||
| 21 | 2 | Chompers Grady Sizemore ** | ||
| 22 | 2 | World Eaters Jose Reyes ** | ||
| 23 | 2 | Pumbaas Lance Berkman | ||
| 24 | 2 | Gomers Manny Ramirez | ||
| 25 | 2 | Red Menace Brian Roberts | ||
| 26 | 2 | Thunder Ichiro | ||
| 27 | 2 | Armadillos Victor Martinez | ||
| 28 | 2 | Jordan Almonds Carlos Beltran ** | ||
| 29 | 2 | Lugnuts Justin Morneau | ||
| 30 | 2 | Cooperstown Garrett Atkins | ||
| 31 | 2 | City Superheroes Aramis Ramirez | ||
| 32 | 2 | Army of Darkness Miguel Tejada | ||
| 33 | 3 | Army of Darkness Todd Helton | ||
| 34 | 3 | City Superheroes Joe Mauer | ||
| 35 | 3 | Cooperstown Michael Young | ||
| 36 | 3 | Lugnuts Hideki Matsui | ||
| 37 | 3 | Jordan Almonds Carlos Guillen | ||
| 38 | 3 | Armadillos Khalil Greene | ||
| 39 | 3 | Thunder Dice-K * | ||
| 40 | 3 | Red Menace Derrek Lee | ||
| 41 | 3 | Gomers Ian Kinsler | ||
| 42 | 3 | Pumbaas Adam Dunn | ||
| 43 | 3 | World Eaters Paul Konerko | ||
| 44 | 3 | Chompers Kelly Johnson | ||
| 45 | 3 | Gluteus Maximus Bobby Abreu | ||
| 46 | 3 | Carpet Cleaners Magglio Ordonez * | ||
| 47 | 3 | Peanut Gallery Vernon Wells | ||
| 48 | 3 | Monkey Butlers Chone Figgins | ||
| 49 | 4 | Monkey Butlers Roy Halladay | ||
| 50 | 4 | Peanut Gallery Josh Beckett * | ||
| 51 | 4 | Carpet Cleaners Rafael Furcal | ||
| 52 | 4 | Gluteus Maximus Mike Lowell | ||
| 53 | 4 | Chompers Andruw Jones | ||
| 54 | 4 | World Eaters Jorge Posada | ||
| 55 | 4 | Pumbaas Kevin Youkilis | ||
| 56 | 4 | Gomers Torii Hunter * | ||
| 57 | 4 | Red Menace Scott Kazmir | ||
| 58 | 4 | Thunder Placido | ||
| 59 | 4 | Armadillos Adam LaRoche | ||
| 60 | 4 | Jordan Almonds Dan Haren | ||
| 61 | 4 | Lugnuts Carlos Zambrano | ||
| 62 | 4 | Cooperstown Felix Hernandez | ||
| 63 | 4 | City Superheroes Roy Oswalt | ||
| 64 | 4 | Army of Darkness Gary Sheffield | ||
| 65 | 5 | Army of Darkness John Lackey * | ||
| 66 | 5 | City Superheroes Jeff Francoeur | ||
| 67 | 5 | Cooperstown Josh Hamilton | ||
| 68 | 5 | Lugnuts Chris Young (P) | ||
| 69 | 5 | Jordan Almonds Jason Bay | ||
| 70 | 5 | Armadillos Chris Young (OF) | ||
| 71 | 5 | Thunder Edgar Renteria | ||
| 72 | 5 | Red Menace Juan Pierre | ||
| 73 | 5 | Gomers Carlos Delgado | ||
| 74 | 5 | Pumbaas Brett Myers | ||
| 75 | 5 | World Eaters Rickie Weeks | ||
| 76 | 5 | Chompers K-Rod | ||
| 77 | 5 | Gluteus Maximus Jon Papelbon | ||
| 78 | 5 | Carpet Cleaners Adrian Beltre | ||
| 79 | 5 | Peanut Gallery Orlando Cabrera | ||
| 80 | 5 | Monkey Butlers Chipper Jones * | ||
| 81 | 6 | Monkey Butlers C Wang | ||
| 82 | 6 | Peanut Gallery Alex Gordon | ||
| 83 | 6 | Carpet Cleaners Ivan Rodriguez | ||
| 84 | 6 | Gluteus Maximus Dontrelle Willis | ||
| 85 | 6 | Chompers Joe Nathan | ||
| 86 | 6 | World Eaters Hank Blalock | ||
| 87 | 6 | Pumbaas Edwin Encarnacion | ||
| 88 | 6 | Gomers Josh Fields | ||
| 89 | 6 | Red Menace Delmon Young | ||
| 90 | 6 | Thunder Eric Chavez | ||
| 91 | 6 | Armadillos Cole Hamels * | ||
| 92 | 6 | Jordan Almonds Javier Vazquez | ||
| 93 | 6 | Lugnuts Yunel Escobar | ||
| 94 | 6 | Cooperstown CC Sabathia * | ||
| 95 | 6 | City Superheroes Aaron Rowand | ||
| 96 | 6 | Army of Darkness Pat Burrell | ||
| 97 | 7 | Army of Darkness Brandon Philips * | ||
| 98 | 7 | City Superheroes John Maine | ||
| 99 | 7 | Cooperstown Dustin Pedroia | ||
| 100 | 7 | Lugnuts Raul Ibanez | ||
| 101 | 7 | Jordan Almonds Nick Swisher ** | ||
| 102 | 7 | Armadillos Orlando Hudson | ||
| 103 | 7 | Thunder Alex Rios * | ||
| 104 | 7 | Red Menace Josh Willingham | ||
| 105 | 7 | Gomers Fausto Carmona | ||
| 106 | 7 | Pumbaas Bengie Molina | ||
| 107 | 7 | World Eaters Fukodome | ||
| 108 | 7 | Chompers Jarrod Saltamachia | ||
| 109 | 7 | Gluteus Maximus Jim Thome | ||
| 110 | 7 | Carpet Cleaners Nick Markakis * | ||
| 111 | 7 | Peanut Gallery Michael Cuddyer | ||
| 112 | 7 | Monkey Butlers Jason Varitek | ||
| 113 | 8 | Monkey Butlers Adam Wainwright | ||
| 114 | 8 | Peanut Gallery Bobby Jenks | ||
| 115 | 8 | Carpet Cleaners John Smoltz | ||
| 116 | 8 | Gluteus Maximus Aaron Hill | ||
| 117 | 8 | Chompers Jeremy Bonderman | ||
| 118 | 8 | World Eaters Jeff Francis | ||
| 119 | 8 | Pumbaas Billy Butler | ||
| 120 | 8 | Gomers Kenji Johjima ** | ||
| 121 | 8 | Red Menace Conor Jackson | ||
| 122 | 8 | Thunder Jason Giambi | ||
| 123 | 8 | Armadillos Mariano Rivera | ||
| 124 | 8 | Jordan Almonds Freddy Sanchez | ||
| 125 | 8 | Lugnuts Oliver Perez | ||
| 126 | 8 | Cooperstown T Saito | ||
| 127 | 8 | City Superheroes Tulowitzski * | ||
| 128 | 8 | Army of Darkness Billy Wagner | ||
| 129 | 9 | Army of Darkness Johnny Damon | ||
| 130 | 9 | City Superheroes Jermaine Dye ** | ||
| 131 | 9 | Cooperstown Ben Sheets | ||
| 132 | 9 | Lugnuts Brian McCann ** | ||
| 133 | 9 | Jordan Almonds Ian Snell | ||
| 134 | 9 | Armadillos Francisco Cordero | ||
| 135 | 9 | Thunder Pedro Martinez | ||
| 136 | 9 | Red Menace Ramon Hernandez | ||
| 137 | 9 | Gomers Trevor Hoffman | ||
| 138 | 9 | Pumbaas Stephen Drew | ||
| 139 | 9 | World Eaters AJ Burnett | ||
| 140 | 9 | Chompers David DeJesus | ||
| 141 | 9 | Gluteus Maximus Jeremy Hermida | ||
| 142 | 9 | Carpet Cleaners Howie Kendrick | ||
| 143 | 9 | Peanut Gallery Matt Cain * | ||
| 144 | 9 | Monkey Butlers Eric Byrnes * | ||
| 145 | 10 | Monkey Butlers Ryan Garko | ||
| 146 | 10 | Peanut Gallery Aubrey Huff | ||
| 147 | 10 | Carpet Cleaners Philip Hughes | ||
| 148 | 10 | Gluteus Maximus BJ Upton * | ||
| 149 | 10 | Chompers Bobby Crosby | ||
| 150 | 10 | World Eaters Ken Griffey | ||
| 151 | 10 | Pumbaas Curtis Granderson * | ||
| 152 | 10 | Gomers Willy Taveras | ||
| 153 | 10 | Red Menace Melky Cabrera | ||
| 154 | 10 | Thunder Ted Lilly | ||
| 155 | 10 | Armadillos Carlos Quentin | ||
| 156 | 10 | Jordan Almonds Brad Lidge | ||
| 157 | 10 | Lugnuts JJ Putz * | ||
| 158 | 10 | Cooperstown JD Drew | ||
| 159 | 10 | City Superheroes Jacoby Ellsbury | ||
| 160 | 10 | Army of Darkness Troy Glaus | ||
| 161 | 11 | Army of Darkness Tim Hudson | ||
| 162 | 11 | City Superheroes Joe Blanton | ||
| 163 | 11 | Cooperstown Austin Kearns | ||
| 164 | 11 | Lugnuts Luke Scott | ||
| 165 | 11 | Jordan Almonds Chad Billingsley | ||
| 166 | 11 | Armadillos Jon Lester | ||
| 167 | 11 | Thunder Paul LoDuca | ||
| 168 | 11 | Red Menace Geovany Soto | ||
| 169 | 11 | Gomers Kevin Kouzmanoff | ||
| 170 | 11 | Pumbaas Carlos Ruiz | ||
| 171 | 11 | World Eaters John Garland | ||
| 172 | 11 | Chompers Felipe Lopez | ||
| 173 | 11 | Gluteus Maximus Y Betancourt | ||
| 174 | 11 | Carpet Cleaners Huston Street | ||
| 175 | 11 | Peanut Gallery Jose Lopez | ||
| 176 | 11 | Monkey Butlers Cameron Maybin | ||
| 177 | 12 | Monkey Butlers Joba Chamberlain | ||
| 178 | 12 | Peanut Gallery Rich Hill | ||
| 179 | 12 | Carpet Cleaners Evan Longoria | ||
| 180 | 12 | Gluteus Maximus Chris Snyder | ||
| 181 | 12 | Chompers Casey Kotchman | ||
| 182 | 12 | World Eaters Jeff Kent | ||
| 183 | 12 | Pumbaas Matt Garza | ||
| 184 | 12 | Gomers Justin Verlander ** | ||
| 185 | 12 | Red Menace Brandon Webb ** | ||
| 186 | 12 | Thunder Lyle Overbay | ||
| 187 | 12 | Armadillos Frank Thomas | ||
| 188 | 12 | Jordan Almonds Jhonny Peralta | ||
| 189 | 12 | Lugnuts Ryan Zimmerman ** | ||
| 190 | 12 | Cooperstown Andy Pettite | ||
| 191 | 12 | City Superheroes Todd Jones | ||
| 192 | 12 | Army of Darkness Kurt Suzuki | ||
| 193 | 13 | Army of Darkness Bronson Arroyo | ||
| 194 | 13 | City Superheroes Rich Harden | ||
| 195 | 13 | Cooperstown Barry Bonds | ||
| 196 | 13 | Lugnuts Chris Duncan | ||
| 197 | 13 | Jordan Almonds Jay Bruce | ||
| 198 | 13 | Armadillos Gary Matthews | ||
| 199 | 13 | Thunder T. Iguchi | ||
| 200 | 13 | Red Menace Hanley Ramirez ** | ||
| 201 | 13 | Gomers Coco Crisp | ||
| 202 | 13 | Pumbaas Brian Giles | ||
| 203 | 13 | World Eaters Nate Robertson | ||
| 204 | 13 | Chompers Jack Cust | ||
| 205 | 13 | Gluteus Maximus Joey Votto | ||
| 206 | 13 | Carpet Cleaners Rick Ankiel | ||
| 207 | 13 | Peanut Gallery AJ Pierzynski | ||
| 208 | 13 | Monkey Butlers Chase Headley | ||
| 209 | 14 | Monkey Butlers Tom Gorzellany | ||
| 210 | 14 | Peanut Gallery Randy Winn | ||
| 211 | 14 | Carpet Cleaners Adam Jones | ||
| 212 | 14 | Gluteus Maximus Brandon Wood | ||
| 213 | 14 | Chompers Mike Jacobs | ||
| 214 | 14 | World Eaters Jason Isringhausen | ||
| 215 | 14 | Pumbaas Rafael Soriano | ||
| 216 | 14 | Gomers Ryan Theriot | ||
| 217 | 14 | Red Menace Nick Johnson | ||
| 218 | 14 | Thunder Casey Blake | ||
| 219 | 14 | Armadillos Lastings Milledge | ||
| 220 | 14 | Jordan Almonds Garrett Anderson | ||
| 221 | 14 | Lugnuts Andre Ethier | ||
| 222 | 14 | Cooperstown Sean Marcum | ||
| 223 | 14 | City Superheroes Ervin Santana | ||
| 224 | 14 | Army of Darkness Michael Bourn | ||
| 225 | 15 | Army of Darkness Daric Barton | ||
| 226 | 15 | City Superheroes Richie Sexson | ||
| 227 | 15 | Cooperstown Xavier Nady | ||
| 228 | 15 | Lugnuts Mark Teahen | ||
| 229 | 15 | Jordan Almonds Matt Capps | ||
| 230 | 15 | Armadillos Jeremy Accardo | ||
| 231 | 15 | Thunder Travis Buck | ||
| 232 | 15 | Red Menace Mark Reynolds | ||
| 233 | 15 | Gomers Marcus Thames | ||
| 234 | 15 | Pumbaas Julio Lugo | ||
| 235 | 15 | World Eaters Ty Wigginton * | ||
| 236 | 15 | Chompers Asdrubal Cabrera | ||
| 237 | 15 | Gluteus Maximus Jorge Cantu | ||
| 238 | 15 | Carpet Cleaners Kelvim Escobar | ||
| 239 | 15 | Peanut Gallery Joe Borowski | ||
| 240 | 15 | Monkey Butlers JR Towles | ||
| 241 | 16 | Monkey Butlers JJ Hardy * | ||
| 242 | 16 | Peanut Gallery Derek Lowe | ||
| 243 | 16 | Carpet Cleaners Scott Rolen | ||
| 244 | 16 | Gluteus Maximus Dustin McGowan | ||
| 245 | 16 | Chompers Rocco Baldelli | ||
| 246 | 16 | World Eaters Clay Buchholz | ||
| 247 | 16 | Pumbaas Chad Tracy | ||
| 248 | 16 | Gomers Brad Penny ** | ||
| 249 | 16 | Red Menace Andrew Miller | ||
| 250 | 16 | Thunder Kenny Rogers | ||
| 251 | 16 | Armadillos Matt Antonelli | ||
| 252 | 16 | Jordan Almonds Ryan Braun * | ||
| 253 | 16 | Lugnuts Ian Kennedy | ||
| 254 | 16 | Cooperstown Barry Zito | ||
| 255 | 16 | City Superheroes Ryan Doumit | ||
| 256 | 16 | Army of Darkness hiroki kuroda | ||
| 257 | 17 | Army of Darkness chad cordero | ||
| 258 | 17 | City Superheroes Joe crede | ||
| 259 | 17 | Cooperstown bill hall | ||
| 260 | 17 | Lugnuts erick aybar | ||
| 261 | 17 | Jordan Almonds Ronnie Paulino | ||
| 262 | 17 | Armadillos john buck | ||
| 263 | 17 | Thunder kerry wood | ||
| 264 | 17 | Red Menace Zack Greinke | ||
| 265 | 17 | Gomers Corey Patterson | ||
| 266 | 17 | Pumbaas Dan Uggla ** | ||
| 267 | 17 | World Eaters Chuck James | ||
| 268 | 17 | Chompers Mark DeRosa | ||
| 269 | 17 | Gluteus Maximus Francisco Liriano * | ||
| 270 | 17 | Carpet Cleaners Ubaldo Jimenez | ||
| 271 | 17 | Peanut Gallery Pedro Feliz | ||
| 272 | 17 | Monkey Butlers Shane Victorino * | ||
| 273 | 18 | Monkey Butlers Colby Rasmus | ||
| 274 | 18 | Peanut Gallery Ryan Church | ||
| 275 | 18 | Carpet Cleaners Mark Ellis | ||
| 276 | 18 | Gluteus Maximus Rick Porcello | ||
| 277 | 18 | Chompers Brad Hawpe ** | ||
| 278 | 18 | World Eaters James Loney * | ||
| 279 | 18 | Pumbaas James Shields * | ||
| 280 | 18 | Gomers Mark Buerhle | ||
| 281 | 18 | Red Menace Brendan Harris | ||
| 282 | 18 | Thunder Jack Wilson | ||
| 283 | 18 | Armadillos erik bedard ** | ||
| 284 | 18 | Jordan Almonds Homer Bailey | ||
| 285 | 18 | Lugnuts Ian Stewart | ||
| 286 | 18 | Cooperstown Adrian Gonzalez ** | ||
| 287 | 18 | City Superheroes Hunter Pence * | ||
| 288 | 18 | Army of Darkness Jose Guillen | ||
| 289 | 19 | Army of Darkness Yovani Gallardo * | ||
| 290 | 19 | City Superheroes Carlos Pena * | ||
| 291 | 19 | Cooperstown Russell Martin ** | ||
| 292 | 19 | Lugnuts Jered Weaver ** | ||
| 293 | 19 | Jordan Almonds Justin Upton * | ||
| 294 | 19 | Armadillos corey hart * | ||
| 295 | 19 | Thunder Joel Zumaya ** | ||
| 296 | 19 | Red Menace Jose Valverde * | ||
| 297 | 19 | Gomers Eric Gagne | ||
| 298 | 19 | Pumbaas Scott Olsen | ||
| 299 | 19 | World Eaters Matt Kemp * | ||
| 300 | 19 | Chompers Aaron Harang ** | ||
| 301 | 19 | Gluteus Maximus Felix Pie | ||
| 302 | 19 | Carpet Cleaners Tim Lincemun * | ||
| 303 | 19 | Peanut Gallery Johnny Gomes | ||
| 304 | 19 | Monkey Butlers Manny Corpas | ||