| Players being kept for 2005 Season | ||||
| * = 3rd & final year at that draft position. Player cannot be kept next year. | ||||
| Larson Lugnuts: | Michael Young - 6 | Adam Dunn - 9 | Mark Teixeira - 14 * | Hank Blalock - 16 * |
| Ratpack: | Barry Bonds - 1 | Carlos Lee - 11 * | David Ortiz - 17 * | Ben Sheets - 18 |
| Army of Darkness: | Miguel Tejada - 1 | Carl Crawford - 7 | Aubrey Huff - 17 * | Jake Peavy - 18 |
| Monkey Butlers: | Vladimir Guerrero - 1 * | Brad Lidge - 17 | Marcus Giles - 18 * | Chone Figgins - 19 |
| The Real Tigers: | Carlos Delgado - 1 | Derek Jeter - 3 | Adrian Beltre - 13 | |
| World Eaters: | Albert Pujols - 1 * | Hideki Matsui - 7 | Javy Lopez - 10 * | Melvin Mora - 13 |
| Jordan Almonds: | Carlos Beltran - 1 | Keith Foulke - 6 | Mark Loretta - 11 | Randy Winn - 14 |
| Thunder in Paradise: | Randy Johnson - 1 | Jorge Posada - 3 * | Jason Schmidt - 11 * | |
| Diablos Blancos: | Nomar Garciaparra - 1 * | Manny Ramirez - 2 * | Tim Hudson - 3 | Ivan Rodriguez - 4 * |
| Armadillos: | Alfonso Soriano - 1 | Josh Beckett - 2 | Austin Kearns - 9 * | Khalil Greene - 19 * |
| Red Menace: | Jimmy Rollins - 7 | Miguel Cabrera - 17 * | Johan Santana - 18 * | David Wright - 19 |
| Pumbaas: | Alex Rodriguez - 1 * | Mark Prior - 4 * | Gary Sheffield - 5 * | Jason Bay - 19 |
| Killer Bees: | Bobby Abreu - 2 | Carlos Zambrano - 10 | Carlos Guillen - 17 | Dmitri Young - 19 * |
| Peanut Gallery: | Mark Mulder - 6 | Derrek Lee - 9 * | Victor Martinez - 10 | Octavio Dotel - 16 * |
| Mechastreisand: | Jim Thome - 3 | Roy Oswalt - 4 | Aramis Ramirez - 6 | Scott Podsednik - 9 |
| Expansion Team 1: | Todd Helton - 1 * | Scott Rolen - 2 | Eric Gagne - 3 * | Matt Clement - 12 |