| Players being kept for 2009 Season | |||||||||||
| * = 3rd & final year at that draft position. Player cannot be kept next year. | |||||||||||
| Army of Darkness | John Lackey - 5* | Brandon Phillips - 7* | Jair Jurrjens - 18 | David Price - 19 | |||||||
| Gluteus Maximus | BJ Upton - 10* | Francisco Liriano - 17* | Ricky Nolasco - 18 | Alexei Ramirez - 19 | |||||||
| Red Menace | Rich Harden - 13 | Zack Greinke - 17 | Jose Valverde - 18* | B.J. Ryan - 19 | |||||||
| Cooperstown Cracker Jacks | Josh Hamilton - 5 | C.C. Sabathia - 6* | Dustin Pedroia - 7 | Cliff Lee - 19 | |||||||
| The City's Superheroes | David Wright - 1* | Troy Tulowitzski - 8* | Ervin Santana - 14 | Hunter Pence - 18* | |||||||
| Thunder in Paradise | Ichiro - 2 | Dice-K - 3* | Ted Lilly - 10 | Kerry Wood - 17 | |||||||
| Topeka Monkey Butlers | Roy Halladay - 4 | Chipper Jones - 5* | JJ Hardy - 16* | Shane Victorino - 17* | |||||||
| Carla | Manny Ramirez - 2 | Ian Kinsler - 3 | Kevin Kouzmanoff - 11 | ||||||||
| Guadalajaran Armadillos | Jacoby Ellsbury - 10 | Ryan Doumit - 16 | Corey Hart - 19* | ||||||||
| Kansas City Pumbaas | Stephen Drew - 9 | Curtis Granderson - 10* | Joey Votto - 13 | Mike Aviles - 19 | |||||||
| Larson Lugnuts | Justin Morneau - 2 | Carlos Zambrano - 4 | Raul Ibanez - 7 | Andre Ethier - 14 | |||||||
| Chompers | K Rod - 5 | David Dejesus - 9 | Jed Lowrie - 18 | Kelly Shoppach - 19 | |||||||
| Sunshine Carpet Cleaners | Nick Markakis - 7* | Evan Longoria - 12 | Tim Lincecum - 18* | Ryan Dempster - 19 | |||||||
| The Jordan Almonds | Dan Haren - 4 | Jason Bay - 5 | Chad Billingsley - 11 | Ryan Braun - 16* | |||||||
| The Peanut Gallery | Josh Beckett - 4* | Matt Cain - 9* | Aubrey Huff - 10 | Johnny Cueto - 19 | |||||||
| World Eaters | AJ Burnett - 9 | Geovany Soto - 11 | James Loney - 18* | Matt Kemp - 19* | |||||||